Hartford files suit against Washington County

By Matthew Rice

 

Hartford Town Supervisor Dana Haff and the rest of the town board have had enough.

Tired of Washington County’s refusal to discuss or mediate a matter where the town feels it is entitled to reimbursement, Hartford announced plans to file suit against the county for funds owed from a host agreement involving the former potential dump site.

Although the permit to locate a dump at the site was not renewed in 2011, and it appears unlikely a waste site will be built, town officials said they still feel they are owed money under the terms of the agreement relating to the dump.

Hartford’s Supervisor, Dana Haff, announced the town voted during its regular monthly meeting to file suit seeking payments spelled out in a 1994 Host Package Agreement between the county and the town.

In a statement Haff compared the county to a bully taking the town’s lunch money and comparing any courtroom to the principal’s office.

Under the contract, the county agreed to pick up expenses relating to the maintenance of Eldridge Lane, a narrow dirt road off of county Route 196 which had been slated at the site of an ash dump for the then new Warren-Washington county joint burn plant project. Another portion of the agreement was supposed to pay Hartford $8,000 per year in addition to monies relating to hosting the disposal facility.

Town attorney Robert Winn said the county paid just $15,000 and stopped paying on the host agreement and did not pay towards maintenance costs.

Winn said the funds Hartford is owed represent a “significant benefit” to the town and as a result officials feel they must pursue those funds.

The two municipalities entered into a binding contract so the matter is pretty straight forward – the county said they would pay and they have to honor that contract, Winn said.

“We feel it’s going to be a straightforward lawsuit,” Winn said.

Winn said Supervisor Haff has requested and been rebuffed on numerous occasion when requesting face to face discussion or mediation in the matter.

“It didn’t even have to be binding,” Winn said.

The matter was probably one best suited for arbitration versus litigation, but the county’s refusal to discuss the matter left Hartford with little choice, Winn said.

Winn said he was confident in the town’s position because initially the county claimed it owed Hartford nothing, later sent a letter stating about $16,000 would be paid to the town, only to pay still more.

The county paid Hartford town and school district nearly $20,000 during the summer of 2011, but did so without discussing the matter with representatives from Hartford, Winn said, only letters were exchanged between lawyers.

Washington County Attorney Roger Wickes said he had no comment regarding the suit when reached Jan 12.

“It’s hard to comment on something that hasn’t been filed,” Wickes said. “We’re not going to comment on something that’s going to be litigated so I guess we talk in court if that’s what it comes to,” he said.  

Asked if he thought compromise remained possible even with a pending suit, Wickes said he was not optimistic. “It’s hard to arbitrate between the two positions, so I doubt it,” he said.   

 

 

 

 

Comments

comments

Read more in this week's Sentinel in newsstands now or click here to read right now with our e-edition.

Railroaders roll over Horde, 55-12

white football4

By Matthew Saari An age-old rivalry was revived Friday night when the Whitehall football team traveled to neighboring Granville for […]

Hampton native, wife travel world

Ethan Atwood1

By Matthew Saari When the Whitehall Times last spoke with Hampton native Ethan Atwood, a Whitehall High School graduate, he […]

McEachron ‘made the world a better place’

mceachron

By Keith Harrington Before Wednesday night’s game against Warrensburg under the lights, the scoreboard at Granville’s field hockey field was […]

Brooks resigns from fire company

WVFC Fire House

By Matthew Saari The Whitehall Volunteer Fire Company may have just lost their president. Mayor Phil Smith opened Tuesday’s village […]

Weekender – 10/13/17

Weekender 10_13_17.pdf-web.pdf

Lakes Region Freepress – 10/13/17

Lakes_10_13_17.pdf-web.pdf

North Country Freepress – 10/13/17

FreePress_10_13_17.pdf-web.pdf

Northshire Freepress – 10/13/17

Northshire_10_13_17.pdf-web.pdf

518 Wheels – 10/13/17

518 Wheels 10-9-17.pdf-web.pdf

Granville-Whitehall face off Friday night

GranvilleWhitehall

By Keith Harrington An event that was once billed as “one of New York’s longest-running high school football rivalries” will […]

Act 46: Pawlet-Rupert merger committee votes for choice

act 46

By Krystle S. Morey The seven-member committee tasked with merging Pawlet and Rupert school districts under Vermont’s Act 46 voted […]

Braymer monument to get facelift

20171010_105317 cmyk

By Krystle S. Morey It was during a quiet family hike when Dan Williams realized the poor shape the Braymer […]