Is police road to Whitehall Central School even legally needed?

B y Lee Tugas

The idea of a town and village municipal agreement granting village police legal jurisdiction on school may not be needed.

According to Whitehall Supervisor George Armstrong, village police may already have all of the legal jurisdiction and insurance protection on school grounds that it needs, without drafting a new piece of local legislation.

And Village Police Chief Matt Dickinson confirmed that village police can act as a surrogate for the county Sheriff’s Department in case of “emergencies.”

The key word is emergency

The key word is the word emergency. A copy of a memo from village Attorney Erika Sellar Ryan to Mayor Peter Telisky states that absent an agreement between the town and the village “the jurisdiction of the village police is limited to the jurisdictional boundaries of the village.”

But Chief Dickinson last week said village police can respond to “emergency” calls from the school when authorized by the Washington County Sheriff’s Department.

That opinion by is confirmed by the letter from Sellar to Telisky.

The letter describes “emergency circumstances” that warrant village police on school grounds:

“Some examples would be,” the letter states, “an intruder at the school, believed to be dangerous; a hostage situation; a fire necessitating the direction of traffic; an event whereby county dispatch requested backup or intervention by village police.”

The letter also states exactly where the village police have no authority on school grounds:

Only a drug search by state police or sheriff’s deputies is legally valid. A search by village police would simply result in “forfeiture of evidence.” Village police have no business, the letter states, inserting themselves in a “common dispute at the school between a teacher and a student,” nor can village police ‘find’ or ‘happen across’ a crime or offense at the school and take action.

The letter makes it explicit that the only time village police can legally act at Whitehall Central School is in response to those emergency situations outlined in the letter. And that, Armstrong said, is pretty much what he was told, word for word, by the Washington County Sheriff.

For that reason, he “sees no need to do anything” about drafting a joint municipal agreement with the village. “Right now, I have no plans to pursue the idea any further,” Armstrong said.

Good idea meets better idea

The original idea to draft a joint town and village municipal agreement was suggested by Village Trustee Ken Bartholomew in early autumn. At the time the village and town boards were concerned that village police might not have full legal authority and liability protection on school grounds.

But in the wake of this legal opinion by Sellar, that mindset may have changed.

In an email to all village police officers, Bartholomew writes as follows:

“As of this date, Nov. 14, 2013, no village of Whitehall police officer will be on Whitehall Central School property unless there are ‘emergency circumstances’ or county dispatch requests back-up or intervention by the village police in an emergency.

“Violation of this directive would result in no protection for the officer as he or she would be operating outside the scope of their authority,” the email states.

Comments

comments

Read more in this week's Times in newsstands now or click here to read right now with our e-edition.

Weekender – 03/27/15

Northshire Freepress – 03/27/15

Lakes Region Freepress – 03/27/15

North Country Freepress – 03/27/15

Classifieds 03/25/14

Search for Sasquatch resumes, forty years later

Statue 2

By Dan King It’s been 40 years since the first reported Sasquatch sighting in Whitehall and now the quest to […]

Apathy leaves trustee seat vacant

Candidate pic Ken Bartholomew

By Dan King Whitehall’s mayor-elect, Ken Bartholomew was hoping someone would emerge to take his old trustee position, but that […]

Jane O’Shea resigns, cites issues with board

Jane O'Shea BW

By Derek Liebig A Granville principal is resigning at the end of the school year because of a disagreement over […]

Whitehall Elks honor three for service

New Elks officers are sworn into office

By Dan King Ken McKee, an old Whitehall Elk, used to tell his kids that the acronym BPOE stood for […]

Reelected, incumbents face challenges

By Derek Liebig Members of the Granville Village Board will be together for at least two more years. Incumbents Dean […]

Keough to plant community garden

Jensen Keough

By Dan King A Whitehall High School student has come up with a creative way to support local charity and […]

Whitehall school officials want bobsled club back

By Dan King Until this year, Whitehall High School was the only school in the country with a bobsled club, […]