Preliminary hearing for arsonist, district attorney to push murder charge

4-8 015By Jaime Thomas

Stephen Gyarmathy did not intend to burn the building at 44 Mettowee St. when he poured gasoline on the stairwell and set it alight.

At least that’s what he said in a written statement taken by state police hours after the deed was done. On Thursday, Gyarmathy had a preliminary hearing in Granville village court for second-degree arson charges.

The charges stem from a March 25 fire he admitted to starting that left 11 residents temporarily homeless, endangered them and caused minor harm to one of them.

After his defense attorney, Michael Mercure, questioned investigator Joseph Bearor on the circumstances surrounding Gyarmathy’s statement, Village Justice Paul Manchester found cause to send him to the grand jury in Washington County.

And Washington County District Attorney Kevin Kortright said he intends to upgrade the charges for both Gyarmathy and his accomplice, Joseph Guerrier, to attempted murder.

“We believe the facts of the case support attempted murder,” Kortright said on Thursday, referring to the 15 people who were in the building at the time of the fire.

Among other questions during the hearing, Mercure asked Bearor how the defendant originally became a lead.

“We interviewed any people with connections to those in the apartment building or those with a possible beef,” Bearor said. Mercure went on to ask a number of questions ensuring Gyarmathy was free to leaving during interrogation, as he was not in custody.

However, Gyarmathy stayed and confessed his motive and means for starting the fire. During the hearing, he kept his head down and occasionally shook it in apparent disapproval of his own actions.

Guerrier chose not to have a preliminary hearing but still faces charges.

Kortright said the case should be complete from indictment through trial within three months. He said he has much praise for Granville police, state and county fire investigators and state police.

“I can’t say enough about what a professional job they did,” Kortright said.

Comments

comments

Read more in this week's Sentinel in newsstands now or click here to read right now with our e-edition.

Tags: , , ,

Obituary: James Kelly

James Kelly obit photo

Wells, VT –  James Kelly (Jim), 76 years of age, of Wells, VT; passed away Friday January 17, 2020 in […]

Obituary: Robert Joseph Pekar Sr

Robert Joseph Pekar Sr obit photo

Robert Joseph Pekar Sr., 82 of  Bonita Springs, Fl. passed away Tuesday, January 14, 2020 at JoAnne’s House in Bonita […]

Lakes Region Freepress – 01/17/20

Lakes_1_17_20.pdf-web.pdf

North Country Freepress – 01/17/20

FreePress_1_17_20.pdf-web.pdf

518 Wheels – 01/15/20

518 Wheels 1_17_20.pdf-web.pdf

Classifieds 01/16/20

Classifides 1_15_20.pdf-web.pdf

Ferguson retracts apology

dresden

By Matthew Saari Two weeks after issuing a formal, public apology to town clerk Marcinda Wilbur, Dresden supervisor Paul Ferguson […]

Granville man awarded $4.8 million

loomis gibson crash

By PJ Ferguson   David Gibson of Granville has been awarded more than $4.8 million for the 2015 drunk-driving crash […]

Village’s goal: Reopen Williams Street

North Williams Closed

By PJ Ferguson Progress is finally being made towards repairing the damaged canal wall and re-opening North Williams Street. Albeit […]

Town grilled by residents over bank purchase

td bank

By Matthew Saari The interrogation of local officials which began at a Granville Village Board last Monday continued on Thursday […]

Martin Luther King Jr. events in the region

mlk

Martin Luther King Jr. events Martin Luther King Jr. Day celebrates the birthday of this influential American civil rights leader. […]

Obituary: William Richard Dupont, Jr.

Dupont obit photo

William Richard Dupont, Jr., 65, passed away on Wednesday, Jan. 8, 2020, at Albany Medical Center following a long illness. […]