By Matthew Saari

Washington County’s supervisors are at odds over who should be in charge of the county’s $120 million budget.

Last week Easton supervisor Dan Shaw was re-elected to the position of county budget officer, despite receiving only seven votes from his fellow supervisors compared to nine for his challenger, Hebron supervisor Brian Campbell.

Hebron supervisor Brian Campbell

“That was quite a fiasco,” said Shaw, who noted the whole process was reminiscent of when he beat out Campbell two years ago. “That division or disagreement has been going on since then.”

Shaw’s reelection was made possible because the Board of Supervisors utilizes a weighted vote system wherein the towns with the higher populations are given more weight and thus more power. For example, the Town of Hampton carries a weight of 69 compared with 760 for the Town of Kingsbury.

The seven votes cast in Shaw’s favor won him the budget officer seat by a 2,368-1,844 margin.

“When he presents things, it’s black and white…nothing real fancy,” said Whitehall supervisor John Rozell, who voted for Shaw.

This will be Shaw’s second term as budget officer. He was initially elected to the position in 2018 when he beat out Campbell, who had served in the post for eight years.

“We were pretty happy with the way Brian did things,” said Granville town supervisor Matt Hicks, who voted for Campbell, who previously had held the position.

Said Hampton supervisor Dave O’Brien, who voted for Campbell:

“I have only one statement: the responsibility of the Board of Supervisors is to make sure we have the right people in the right jobs to serve the needs of the 65,000 residents of Washington County.”

Granville supervisor Matt Hicks

The controversy is rooted in how Shaw allegedly mismanaged the 2020 budget process, which required more than $1 million in adjustments, put forward by Hicks and Campbell.

The amendments include $127,166 for personnel adjustments; $3,000 stipend for real property director Laura Chadwick; $100,000 for public works equipment and $1.1 million for county roads and bridges.

Hicks noted that under Shaw’s budget, the county’s highway budget included only enough funding for paving 7.5 miles of roadway, compared with the 20 miles which made it in the amended, approved budget.

“We were going to pave a lot less roads…that’s not really acceptable,” Hicks said.

“That’s not a good place to be,” agreed Campbell.

Shaw countered that this is nothing but rumor.

“They started a rumor that I cut paving,” he said, noting that the budget was amended to change the paving schedule from resurfacing roads to “full depth reclamation,” essentially tearing and grinding up the roadway and replacing it with brand new asphalt, and no new miles of road were added.

“That’s very expensive to do that,” Shaw added.


This is only a preview of the story published in the Whitehall Times. To read the full story, pick up a print copy of this week’s paper at the newsstand or read it online here.


This is only a preview of the story published in the Granville Sentinel. To read the full story, pick up a print copy of this week’s paper at the newsstand or read it online here.



Read more in this week's Sentinel in newsstands now or click here to read right now with our e-edition.

Read more in this week's Times in newsstands now or click here to read right now with our e-edition.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Gov. Cuomo, Main Street needs a hand from Albany


Covid-19 has completely changed the way we all live. But along with worrying about keeping themselves and their families healthy, […]

County faces financial ‘uncertainties’

The Washington County Board of Supervisors

By PJ Ferguson Washington County officials are clouded by financial uncertainties stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic with County Administrator Chris […]

School slated to resume soon, officials await state guidance

Whitehall High School

By PJ Ferguson As the news develops around the COVID-19 pandemic, the Whitehall Central School District faces some changes and […]

Obituary: David G. Morehouse

David G Morehouse obit photo

Fort Ann, NY – David G. Morehouse passed away at his Dad’s house on March 13, 2020, joining his parents […]

Obituary: David J. Little

David Little obit photo

Middle Granville, NY – David J. Little, age 60, passed away on March 29, 2020 at his home, with his […]

Obituary: Crispen Winterburn

Crispen Winterburn, 49, of Manchester, NH, died suddenly at his home on Tuesday, March 23, 2020 after a brief illness. […]

Town offices close April 1

Granville Town Hall 015

By Matthew Saari The Town of Granville offices will be closed to the public “until further notice” as of April […]

Village, school elections postponed until June

school vote

By Matthew Saari The elections scheduled for both the Granville village and school boards have been pushed back several months. […]

Vermont schools closed, Granville eyes reopening


By Matthew Saari   Vermont Gov. Phil Scott announced last week that all schools in the Green Mountain State will […]

Washington County: Visitors, stay away

Washington County has declared a state of emergency resulting in the closure of all non-essential departments.

By PJ Ferguson Washington County is urging visitors, weekenders, second-home owners and short-term rental owners to stay away during the […]

Whitehall fiscal health ‘good’

village board

By PJ Ferguson The village of Whitehall is in good fiscal health, according to the annual fiscal stress report by […]

Cumberland Farms robbery suspect arrested

police lights

By PJ Ferguson The Whitehall Cumberland Farms armed robbery suspect has found and arrested, police say. Nathan Kupiec, 21, of […]