By Matthew Saari

A three-hour standoff came to end just after 7 a.m. Tuesday morning after Whitehall police took a 32-year-old local man into custody.

David Downing, of Whitehall, was arrested on a felony fugitive from justice charge in connection with crimes in Fair Haven, Vermont, as well as obstruction of governmental administration and resisting arrest after refusing to cooperate and holding police at bay on South William Street.

Whitehall-Granville police Sgt. Ryan Pedone explained that the incident began Monday evening, with Fair Haven police seeking Downing in connection with several crimes in Vermont.

“That involved burglary and assault,” Pedone said.

At 2:30 a.m. Tuesday, Pedone said, Whitehall police received an extraditable warrant from Vermont, as Downing, a Whitehall resident, had fled back across the border following his alleged crimes in the Green Mountain State.

“We began to observe the residence to ensure he was there,” said Pedone.

At 4 a.m. lights began to come on in the home and Whitehall police attempted to establish phone contact with Downing in a bid to end things peaceably.

“He indicated he would shoot us and dared us to knock on the door,” Pedone said.

When Downing proved unreceptive to police overtures, Pedone said officers began evacuating neighboring residents or advising them to stay indoors with doors locked. Additionally, Pedone requested backup from other agencies including the State Police Special Operations Response Team (SORT).

“I requested SORT’s assistance with negotiators and their tactical team,” Pedone said.

Police continued to try and talk Downing out of the building until about 6 a.m. when he finally came out, only to return to the building minutes later.

Downing came back onto the building’s porch twice more, at one time holding a knife officials said.

“He was non-compliant,” Pedone said, adding Downing continued to taunt police, goading them to come at him.

The standoff came to an end just after 7 a.m. when officers took Downing into custody after a brief struggle. No injuries were reported.

Involved agencies included Whitehall police, Granville police, Washington County Sheriff’s Office, State Police and Skenesborough EMS.

Downing was transported to Washington County Jail for arraignment. Pedone said it is likely he will be remanded as a fugitive from justice charge is not one of the qualifying offenses for a suspect to be released to his own recognizance under New York’s Bail Reform law.

This arrest comes just a week after Downing turned himself into Whitehall police for allegedly assaulting a 27-year-old Skene Street man on July 4.



Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Obituary: Peter A. Larro Jr.

Granville, NY – Peter A. Larro Jr., went to his heavenly home on Thursday, July 30, 2020 at Glens Falls […]

Obituary: Stephen J. Vladyka

Stephen J. Vladyka Obit Photo

Whitehall-Stephen Joseph Vladyka, 79, passed peacefully on August 1, 2020, at his home in Whitehall, NY. Mr. Vladyka was preceded […]

Obituary: Laurence E. Andrews

Larry Andrews[5819] OBIT PHOTO

Granville, NY – Laurence E. Andrews passed away on the family farm at the age of 99, holding hands with […]

Ask Matt – Will there really be new episodes to watch this fall?

Question: With the coronavirus epidemic and social distancing, will there be any new TV episodes this fall? –C Brown Matt […]

Morgan Kohan looks for ‘Love on Harbor Island’


By Barb Oates Lake homes, romance and rescue dogs. We’re all in on Hallmark Channel’s latest original Love on Harbor […]

Rick’s Picks – ABC’s fall lineup


By Rick Gables ABC’s primetime fall lineup will include David E. Kelly’s new drama Big Sky, Kari Lizar’s new comedy […]

ReMIND, ReWIND – Kirk Douglas, the modern movie antihero


Intense and hard-charging, Kirk Douglas didn’t just make great movies; he made movies worth watching. By Stephen Whitty, ReMIND Magazine […]

Novel a ‘love letter’ to Granville, Whitehall

It Gives You Strength paperback cover

By Jay Mullen As he walked around town at the time of Granville’s 40th High School Reunion two summers ago, […]

Scott signs executive order setting Sept. 8 as school opening day

Governor Phil Scott has signed a directive officially setting Tuesday, Sept. 8 as the universal reopening date for Vermont schools. […]

Whitehall outlines school plans

Whitehall Central School District eyes A/B day schedule.

By Jay Mullen Superintendent Patrick Dee outlined the school district’s plan to reopen this fall in a YouTube video posted […]

Compliance officer hired by village

Whitehall Municipal Center.

By Jay Mullen   After about a year of searching for a replacement, the village of Whitehall finally has its […]

Nuisance law approved by village

A proposed law would give the Whitehall Village Board the authority to remove a structure’s license of occupancy.

By Matthew Saari The Village of Whitehall unanimously approved a nuisance property law after fielding only a few comments at […]